French hardware wallet manufacturer Ledger has found itself at the center of an unexpected reputational storm. Although the company's devices were not directly affected in the recent incident, a wave of panic and unfounded accusations swept through the crypto community, forcing Ledger to publicly defend itself. It all started with the high-profile hack of Coldcard wallets from Canadian company Coinkite, in which attackers siphoned off 1,367 BTC.

Boycott without evidence

Well-known crypto blogger MDX called on users in his social media to urgently withdraw funds from Ledger devices, calling the company "fraudulent." As proof, he published photos of a disassembled wallet, supposedly a Ledger Flex model. The images show a swollen battery cell and marks that, according to him, indicate external tampering. As an alternative, he suggested Trezor wallets.

However, attentive commentators quickly recognized this as a common defect—a swollen lithium-ion battery that simply pushed out the case cover. The blogger was immediately accused of hidden advertising for competitors. The situation escalated against the backdrop of the aforementioned Coldcard hack, which triggered such a heated reaction.

Ledger is not Coldcard

Ledger was forced to respond by issuing an official statement. They emphasized that Coinkite's warning applies exclusively to Coldcard Mk3 models and has nothing to do with their products. The key difference lies in the security architecture. In Ledger devices, the random number generator is built directly into the Secure Element chip, providing a full 256 bits of entropy for each seed phrase.

Coldcard, on the other hand, had a software-based generator built on MicroPython, whose state could be predicted, compressing the search space to 40 bits. Ledger's firmware remains closed-source, and its security is confirmed by AIS-31, PTG.2, Common Criteria EAL5+/EAL6+ certifications, and the CSPN scheme from ANSSI. Meanwhile, Coldcard, with its open-source code, had the flaw sitting in a public repository since March 2021, and the company only learned about it on the day of the theft.

This incident is a striking example of how information panic can cause damage even to those unrelated to the problem. In times of crisis, the market reacts emotionally rather than rationally. Investors should rely on technical specifications and audits, not on loud claims on social media.