The failure of the CLARITY Act legislative initiative, aimed at eliminating uncertainty in the regulation of digital assets, will serve as a catalyst for more active actions by U.S. regulators. Instead of waiting for clear legislative guidelines, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) will be forced to independently develop and implement regulatory frameworks for the crypto industry.

This conclusion follows from an analysis of the situation conducted by Bernstein experts. In their view, the absence of a unified law will not halt the regulatory process but will only change its trajectory—regulators will shift from passive waiting to active rulemaking. This, in turn, will lead to the emergence of more detailed and possibly stricter requirements than those that might have been enshrined in law.

Key areas of future clarifications

Analysts highlight several critically important areas in which the SEC and CFTC are likely to be forced to provide official clarifications in the near future:

  • Token classification. The question of which digital assets should be considered securities and which should be considered commodities remains the cornerstone of the entire debate. Without a legislative solution, this issue will be resolved through case law and administrative decisions.
  • DeFi regulation. Decentralized finance presents a particular challenge for traditional regulators. It is expected that special approaches will be developed to identify responsibility in protocols that lack centralized governance.
  • Self-custody of assets. Issues related to custodial services and the right of users to self-custody their funds will also require clear regulatory guidance.
  • Temporary exemptions. To stimulate innovation, temporary relief for initial asset offerings may be introduced, allowing young projects to develop without the immediate application of the full range of requirements.

In my understanding, this dynamic is a double-edged sword. On one hand, active rulemaking could provide the market with much-needed certainty faster than the slow legislative process. On the other hand, the absence of a unified law creates a risk of fragmented and contradictory regulation, which may vary depending on the interpretation of individual commissions. Investors and market participants should prepare for a period of heightened volatility driven by the news flow from Washington and closely monitor signals from the SEC and CFTC.