The recent incident involving Coldcard hardware wallets from the Canadian company Coinkite, in which attackers withdrew 1,367 BTC, triggered an unexpected side effect — a wave of unfounded accusations against the French manufacturer Ledger. Although Ledger devices are not related to the hack, the company is forced to defend itself against growing panic in the crypto community.
Pressure on Ledger is mounting on social media: users are calling for a mass withdrawal of funds from "French" wallets. Popular crypto blogger MDX was particularly active, calling the company "fraudulent" without any solid evidence and publishing photos of a disassembled device, presumably a Ledger Flex model. The images show a swollen battery, but the blogger was quick to claim "traces of tampering by an attacker."
Commentators quickly identified the issue as simple degradation of the lithium-ion battery — a typical defect that caused the device cover to bulge out of the casing. In response, MDX urged users to switch to Trezor wallets, raising suspicions of hidden advertising for a competitor.
Ledger is not Coldcard
Ledger promptly responded to the situation by publishing an official statement. The key difference: in Ledger devices, the random number generator is built directly into the Secure Element chip, providing a full 256 bits of entropy for each seed phrase. In contrast, Coldcard experienced a failure precisely in this critical component — the MicroPython software generator, based on device state and timings, compressed the search space to a mere 40 bits.
Ledger's firmware remains closed-source, and security is confirmed by third-party certifications: AIS-31, PTG.2, Common Criteria EAL5+ and EAL6+, as well as the CSPN scheme from ANSSI. Coldcard, on the other hand, used an open-source model, and the error had been in the public repository since March 2021. However, Coinkite only learned of the issue on the day of the theft.
Notably, the panic around Ledger is a classic example of how reputational risks in the crypto industry spread faster than the threats themselves. Instead of examining the technical details, users succumb to emotions and unverified information. This is a reminder that in matters of security, it is critically important to rely on facts and audits rather than loud claims on social media.