A leading Wall Street asset valuation expert, Professor Aswath Damodaran, is issuing a troubling warning about an impending crisis in the artificial intelligence sector. In his view, the impact will be so severe that small companies will be hit first, while tech giants will be able to withstand it.
The "Magnificent Seven": An Impregnable Fortress or an Illusion?
Damodaran emphasizes that corporations such as Apple, Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon, Nvidia, Meta, and Tesla possess a colossal reserve of free cash flow and a solid balance sheet. This gives them the ability to survive shocks that would prove fatal for less capitalized players. In his latest observations, he notes a troubling trend: the return on AI investments at Meta, Alphabet, and Microsoft is noticeably declining.
"When capital starts flowing out of the AI segment, the focus should be less on the 'Magnificent Seven' and more on smaller players," the professor notes. He cites the recent collapse of the hedge fund Situational Awareness as an indicator of rapidly shifting market sentiment.
Declining Returns: The First Warning Signs
This is not just about expectations but also about concrete metrics. Damodaran analyzes the marginal return on invested capital—that is, the return on every new dollar spent. For the aforementioned giants, this ratio has dropped sharply despite continued growth in spending. This is especially noticeable given the scale of their capital investments.
The situation is already beginning to affect chip manufacturers. After Micron's stock collapse, pressure is being felt across the entire memory sector. However, not everyone views this as a negative signal. Tom Lee of Fundstrat, on the contrary, sees it as a bullish factor, arguing that the growth cycle is not yet complete.
Damodaran warns: if the largest companies cannot deliver profits commensurate with their spending, the balance of power in Big Tech will shift. The sector will become even more capital-intensive and less profitable. Whether the correction will extend beyond niche AI companies remains unclear. Much will depend on whether cloud giants can sustain profit growth rates outpacing their spending in the coming quarters.
My take: Damodaran's warning is not just an academic observation but a clear signal for investors. The AI market is overheated, and fundamental indicators are beginning to speak louder than the hype. Diversification and caution in asset selection within this sector are now critically important, especially when it comes to companies with high debt burdens and no "safety cushion."