A federal court in New York has issued a ruling that sets an important precedent for the prediction market: the motion by the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to temporarily stay the litigation against the Kalshi platform has been denied. The regulator argued that the service's activities fall under the definition of unlicensed gambling, but the court found the commission's arguments insufficiently convincing.
The key reason for the denial was the lack of a high likelihood of CFTC success in the main proceedings, as well as the inability to prove irreparable harm that could be caused if Kalshi continued operating. This is a technical but highly significant defeat for the regulator, which in recent months has been actively trying to restrict the market for political and event derivatives.
Strategic pause until August 7
It is important to note that the CFTC does not lose the right to refile its request. The court set a specific date—August 7—when the regulator can again submit a similar motion. This gives the commission time to revise its arguments and gather additional evidence, but at the same time leaves Kalshi operational until that deadline.
For the market, this is a signal that the judicial system is not yet ready to unconditionally support the CFTC's hardline stance toward prediction platforms. Kalshi, which positions itself as a legal venue for trading outcomes of real-world events, gets a temporary reprieve and the opportunity to continue attracting users.
From a long-term perspective, this ruling creates uncertainty for the entire sector. If the CFTC ultimately loses the case, it could open the floodgates for similar services that are currently cautiously watching developments. However, until August 7, the market will remain in a state of suspended anticipation, and any new lawsuits from the regulator could dramatically change the balance of power.
My comment: The denial of the stay is not a victory for Kalshi, but rather a tactical maneuver by the court, which avoids hasty decisions on a sensitive industry topic. But the fact that the CFTC failed to convince the court of urgency hints at the weakness of its legal position. Investors should closely watch August 7—that is when it will become clear whether the regulator is ready for escalation or will prefer a settlement.