The corporate bitcoin treasury model, which until recently seemed like a flawless growth engine, has cracked. The mechanism that allowed companies to raise capital against their crypto assets now works against them, diluting shareholder value and undermining investor confidence.
Fundamental market shift
On-chain data analysis reveals alarming dynamics: bitcoin reserves in funds and among institutional holders have declined from 1.33 million BTC in May to approximately 1.2 million BTC. This 10% drop in two months is a signal that cannot be ignored. Shares of public companies that accumulated BTC no longer trade at a premium to the net value of their crypto assets. On the contrary, many have fallen to a discount, making further capital raising through new share issues or debt obligations extremely unprofitable.
The Coinbase premium index remains in negative territory, holding at -0.11. This means demand on the US spot market is still being formed at a discount to offshore venues. Exchange inflows also offer little cause for optimism: total BTC deposits to spot platforms amounted to about 3,600 BTC, with only 2,200 BTC going to the ten largest exchanges. Both figures are significantly below long-term averages, indicating not panic and mass sell-offs, but a waning of institutional players' purchasing power.
Catalyst of the crisis
Strategy's approval to sell bitcoins worth up to $1.25 billion became a marker of the collapse of the previous paradigm. The company has already sold approximately $218 million worth of BTC to cover dividends and replenish dollar reserves. This is a forced measure that directly hits shareholders: dilution of stakes becomes inevitable when market capitalization falls below net asset value.
Citi experts cite ETF outflows and potential sales by treasury companies among the key risks for the market. Until the market sees the return of a premium to the shares of such corporations, growth in fund reserves, and recovery of the Coinbase index, the self-financing mechanism will remain broken. Additional pressure comes from Fed Chair Lisa Cook's rhetoric about readiness to raise rates amid inflation concerns — this only heightens uncertainty for risky assets.
My view: The current situation is not just a correction, but a structural break. The model built on endless bitcoin price growth ignored the risk of interest rates and liquidity. Until institutional holders find a new way to monetize their reserves without diluting capital, the discount to NAV will persist, and confidence in the treasury strategy will keep falling.