In the world of hardware crypto wallets, Coldcard has long been considered the gold standard of security. However, a recent public experiment conducted by a well-known researcher under the pseudonym Cole has forced me and many of my colleagues to seriously reconsider this view. This is not just a theoretical study—it is a vivid demonstration of how quickly attackers can drain your balance if you neglect basic security rules.
Experiment Design: Five Wallets, One Challenge
Cole took a Coldcard Mk3 hardware wallet with firmware version 4.1.8 and generated a secret phrase on it. Based on this phrase, he created five different wallets, each with a unique level of protection. 10,800 satoshis were sent to each address to test how quickly hackers could detect and withdraw the funds. All addresses used the bc1q standard and a single key derivation path.
The conditions were as close to reality as possible. The researcher deliberately declined the RBF (Replace-By-Fee) mechanism to avoid skewing the results. The experiment was conducted openly, and the entire process was recorded on video. This is important because it allows us to assess not only the speed of the attack but also the behavior of automated bots.
Shocking Results: Basic Wallet Hacked Instantly
The results were more than telling. The wallet without a password was drained almost instantly. As soon as the transaction entered the mempool, the funds were automatically transferred to a new unknown address. This means that hackers had pre-loaded compromised keys into their bots, which react lightning-fast to any activity.
The remaining four wallets—with passwords of one, two, and three words, as well as with an account number—remained untouched. Even using a single word from the standard BIP39 list as a password proved to be sufficient protection against automated attacks. However, the researcher himself emphasizes that the secret phrase is still considered fully vulnerable if it is not protected by an additional password.
Interestingly, a technical glitch occurred during the experiment: when attempting to directly export public keys to the Sparrow program, the device stopped responding to commands. The researcher had to save CSV files to an SD card. This once again highlights that even the most reliable devices can have unforeseen operational issues.
My Verdict: A Password Is Not a Luxury, But a Necessity
This experiment is a stark reminder that there is no room for overconfidence in the world of cryptocurrencies. Even with a hardware wallet considered one of the most secure, using a bare seed phrase without an additional password is playing with fire. Automated blockchain monitoring systems operate 24/7, and any mistake could cost you all your funds. I strongly urge all Coldcard owners, including the Mk4, Mk5, and Q models, to immediately check whether the password feature is activated. It is the simplest step that could save you from disaster.