In the world of hardware crypto wallets, trust is everything. But a recent public experiment conducted by renowned researcher Cole makes one wonder how protected we really are. During a visual test, he demonstrated that some Coldcard models, positioned as the gold standard of security, can be compromised by attackers in a matter of seconds.

The Essence of the Experiment: A Stress Test

The researcher generated a secret phrase on a Coldcard Mk3 device running firmware version 4.1.8. Based on this phrase, he created five different wallets, each of which received the same amount in satoshis. The goal was simple: to test how quickly hackers could discover and drain these addresses. It is important to note that the vulnerability, based on observations, affects not only the Mk3 but also newer models — the Mk4, Mk5, and even the Q.

For the sake of a clean experiment, the following security options were configured:

  • Standard wallet — without any additional passwords.
  • With a passphrase (1 word) — one word from the standard BIP39 list.
  • With a passphrase (2 words) — a combination of two BIP39 words.
  • With a passphrase (3 words) — three words from the BIP39 list.
  • With an account number — an arbitrary account number (from 1 to 9999).

All wallets used a single address standard (bc1q) and one key derivation path. Each address received 10,800 satoshis. An interesting detail: when attempting to directly export public keys into the Sparrow program, the device froze, forcing the researcher to save the data via CSV files to an SD card.

Shocking Results

The results were more than telling. The base wallet without a passphrase was drained instantly. By the time the mempool explorer was opened, the funds had already been transferred to a new, unknown address. This means that hackers had pre-loaded compromised keys into their bots and automatically monitor for funds appearing on such addresses.

The remaining four accounts, including those protected by passphrases and numbers, remained untouched. However, the very fact that the secret phrase is considered completely vulnerable is beyond doubt. Monitoring of address activity continues in real time.

My analysis: This experiment is not just a demonstration of hacking skills, but a harsh reminder for all cryptocurrency holders. Using a hardware wallet without an additional passphrase (BIP39 passphrase) is like leaving the keys to a safe under the doormat. Even the most reliable devices will not save you if you neglect basic security hygiene principles. I recommend that all Coldcard owners and users of similar devices immediately activate additional protection in the form of a passphrase, so as not to become the next victim of automated bots.