In the world of hardware crypto wallets, security is the main selling point. But a recent public test conducted by a well-known researcher under the pseudonym Cole forces us to look at this premise differently. I carefully studied the results of his experiment, and they are, to say the least, alarming. Cole generated a secret phrase on a Coldcard Mk3 device and created five wallets, each of which received the same amount in satoshis. The goal was to test how quickly attackers could detect and drain the accounts.
Methodology and vulnerable models
For the purity of the test, the researcher chose a Coldcard Mk3 with firmware version 4.1.8. As it turned out, this model proved to be the most susceptible to attack, although the problem, according to his data, also affects newer versions — Mk4, Mk5, and Q. The device automatically generated a new seed phrase, based on which five wallet variants were created: a standard one without a password, one with a one-word, two-word, and three-word password, as well as one with an arbitrary account number. All of them used the same bc1q address standard and the same key derivation path.
Results: the speed of the attack is striking
The key point of the experiment was funding each address with 10,800 satoshis and sending all funds in a single transaction. The outcome was predictable for the base wallet: its balance disappeared instantly. As soon as the transaction entered the mempool, the funds had already been withdrawn to a new unknown address. This indicates that hackers pre-loaded compromised keys into automated bots that scan the network for vulnerable addresses.
The remaining four wallets, including those protected by a multi-word password and a non-zero account number, remained untouched. However, the very fact that the secret phrase is considered fully compromised is a serious signal for all Coldcard owners. Monitoring of address activity continues in real time, and the researcher deliberately refused to return funds via the RBF mechanism to preserve the purity of the experiment.
My comment: This test clearly demonstrates that even "cold" storage is not a panacea if the device has vulnerabilities in key generation. For users, this is a lesson: do not blindly rely on brand reputation, but regularly check the firmware and use additional layers of protection, such as complex BIP39 passphrases. Otherwise, your assets could become easy prey for automated scanners.