A researcher known by the pseudonym Cole conducted a bold public test that exposed a troubling reality for Coldcard hardware wallet owners. His experiment is not just a demonstration of theory, but a vivid proof of how quickly attackers can drain a wallet if the user neglects basic protection.
Methodology and test conditions
For the purity of the experiment, Cole used a Coldcard Mk3 with firmware version 4.1.8 — a model he considers the most vulnerable. However, as it turned out, the issue also affects newer devices: Mk4, Mk5, and even Q. The researcher generated a secret phrase on the device and created five different wallets, each with an identical balance of 10,800 satoshis. All of them used the bc1q address standard and a single key derivation path, ensuring identical conditions.
Here is how the test wallets were configured:
- Standard — without any additional protection.
- With passphrase (1 word) — one word from the standard BIP39 list.
- With passphrase (2 words) — two words from the BIP39 list.
- With passphrase (3 words) — three words from the BIP39 list.
- With account number — an arbitrary account number (from 1 to 9999).
An interesting technical nuance: direct export of public keys to the Sparrow program caused a failure — the device stopped responding to commands. Therefore, the researcher had to save CSV files to an SD card.
Results: the speed of the attack is striking
The findings were shocking but expected. The wallet without a passphrase was drained almost instantly. As soon as Cole opened the mempool explorer, the funds had already been moved to a new unknown address. This means that hackers had pre-loaded compromised keys into their automated bots, which monitor the blockchain in real time.
The remaining four wallets — with passphrases and a non-zero account number — remained untouched. Nevertheless, the very fact that a secret phrase without additional protection is completely vulnerable leaves no doubt. Monitoring of address activity is ongoing.
My professional conclusion: this experiment is a stark reminder that a hardware wallet is not a panacea, but merely one layer of protection. Using a BIP39 passphrase is not a recommendation, but a mandatory requirement for those storing significant amounts. Neglecting this simple rule makes your funds easy prey for automated systems that scan the network 24/7. Do not become the next victim.