A U.S. federal appeals court has overturned a preliminary injunction that blocked Perplexity's AI agent Comet from making purchases on Amazon. This landmark ruling shifts the balance of power in the dispute over the legality of using autonomous algorithms to interact with web platforms.
The court's key argument: actions taken through Comet are initiated and controlled by the end user, not by Perplexity itself. Thus, the company acts merely as a technical intermediary, providing a tool, rather than being an entity that violates the service's terms of use. The court found insufficient grounds for such a harsh measure as an injunction, especially at the preliminary stage of proceedings.
This is the first federal appeals-level decision that directly addresses the legal status of AI agents in the context of accessing commercial online platforms. It sets an important precedent for the entire industry, where autonomous assistants are increasingly used to automate routine operations—from ordering goods to booking services.
However, the legal battle between Amazon and Perplexity is far from over. The main proceedings continue, and the final decision may differ significantly from the interim one. Amazon will likely focus on proving that the mass use of agents damages its infrastructure and violates the user agreement, even if actions are formally taken by a human.
My expert perspective: This ruling is a signal to the market: courts are not yet ready to equate AI agents with independent violators. However, this is a double-edged sword—if platforms begin to more actively implement technical barriers against such tools, the legal battle could shift into the realm of antitrust regulation. Stay tuned for developments—this case will set the tone for years to come.