Hardware wallets are considered the gold standard of security in cryptocurrency, but how invulnerable are they really? I conducted my own research, inspired by recent reports of compromised Coldcard devices, and the results were alarming. During the experiment, I used a Coldcard Mk3 model with firmware 4.1.8, which turned out to be one of the most vulnerable. The issue also affects newer versions — Mk4, Mk5, and even Q.
Test Methodology
I generated a secret phrase on the device and created five wallets, each with an identical balance of 10,800 satoshis. The goal was to test how quickly attackers could detect and withdraw funds from different security configurations. The options included a standard wallet without a password, wallets with a one-word, two-word, and three-word BIP39 passphrase, as well as an account with an arbitrary account number.
For the sake of a clean experiment, all wallets used the same bc1q address standard, a single key derivation path, and one transaction to send funds. However, when attempting to export public keys to Sparrow, the device suddenly stopped responding, and I had to save the data via CSV files to an SD card.
Shocking Results
The base wallet without a password was compromised instantly. As soon as I opened the mempool explorer, the funds had already been transferred to a new unknown address. This means hackers had pre-loaded the compromised keys into automated bots that monitor the network in real time. I deliberately did not return the cryptocurrency via the RBF mechanism to preserve the integrity of the experiment.
The remaining four wallets remained untouched, including the variant with a non-zero account number. However, the secret phrase itself is considered fully vulnerable, and monitoring of address activity continues in real time.
My conclusion as an analyst: this test confirms the critical importance of using a BIP39 passphrase (additional phrase) for hardware wallets. Even a single extra layer of protection can become an insurmountable barrier for automated attacks, while its absence makes funds easy prey. I recommend that all owners of Coldcard and similar devices immediately activate this feature if they have not already done so.