Hardware crypto wallets are widely considered the gold standard of security, but a recent public experiment calls this axiom into question. Renowned researcher Cole conducted a visual test of the Coldcard Mk3's resistance to attacker attacks, and the results were more than alarming.
The essence of the test was as follows: a secret phrase was generated on the device with firmware 4.1.8, from which five wallets with identical parameters were created. Each was funded with 10,800 satoshis, after which the researcher observed who would be the first to "get to" the funds. The entire process was documented on video to eliminate any doubts about its authenticity.
Methodology and test subjects
For the purity of the experiment, a single standard of bc1q addresses and the same key derivation path were used. The five wallets differed only in their level of protection:
- Standard — without an additional passphrase.
- With passphrase (1 word) — one word from the BIP39 list.
- With passphrase (2 words) — two words from BIP39.
- With passphrase (3 words) — three words from BIP39.
- With account number — an arbitrary value from 1 to 9999.
An interesting detail: direct integration with the Sparrow program failed, the device stopped responding to commands, so data export had to be done via CSV files on an SD card.
Results that are frightening
The base wallet without a passphrase was drained instantly. As soon as the transaction entered the mempool, the funds were already moving to a new unknown address. This means that hackers had pre-loaded compromised keys into their bots and automatically monitor any attempts to fund such addresses.
The remaining four accounts, including the variant with the account number, remained untouched. However, the very fact that the secret phrase without additional protection is a "hole" is beyond doubt. Monitoring of address activity continues in real time.
My conclusion as an analyst: this experiment is not a verdict on Coldcard, but a harsh reminder. Even the most reliable hardware is useless if the user ignores basic hygiene rules. The passphrase (BIP39 passphrase) is not an option but a mandatory element of protection, especially for large amounts. By neglecting it, you leave your funds on "display" for automated bots that scan the blockchain in search of easy prey.