Well-known researcher Cole conducted a bold public test to find out how quickly attackers can drain a Coldcard hardware wallet. His findings are shocking: a basic wallet without additional protection loses funds almost instantly, and hackers act faster than one might assume.
How the experiment was conducted
Cole took a Coldcard Mk3 with firmware version 4.1.8 — a model he considers the most vulnerable. The problem, according to him, also affects newer devices: Mk4, Mk5, and Q. The device generated a secret phrase, based on which five wallets with different levels of protection were created:
- A standard wallet without a password.
- A wallet with a one-word BIP39 passphrase.
- A wallet with a two-word BIP39 passphrase.
- A wallet with a three-word BIP39 passphrase.
- A wallet with an arbitrary account number (from 1 to 9999).
For the purity of the experiment, all addresses used the standard bc1q format, a single key derivation path, and 10,800 satoshis were sent to each address. Funds were withdrawn in one single transaction. Interestingly, when attempting to export public keys to Sparrow, the device froze, and the researcher had to save the data to an SD card.
Results: the speed of the attack is striking
The wallet without a password was compromised instantly. As soon as Cole opened the mempool explorer, the funds had already been transferred to a new unknown address. This means that hackers had pre-loaded compromised keys into an auto-bot that monitors the network in real time. The researcher did not attempt to recover the cryptocurrency via RBF (replace-by-fee) — he deliberately preserved the purity of the experiment.
The remaining four wallets remained untouched, including the variant with the account number. However, this is not reassuring: the secret phrase itself is considered fully vulnerable, and monitoring of address activity continues in real time.
My analysis: This experiment is a vivid reminder that a hardware wallet without a passphrase is not a safe, but an open door. Even minimal protection in the form of a single BIP39 word already stops bots, but relying on it is not advisable. Use long passphrases and check device settings before the first deposit. The speed of attackers' response in 2025 demands maximum vigilance from us.