Renowned researcher Cole conducted a bold public experiment to test how quickly attackers respond to vulnerabilities in hardware wallets. The results were shocking: a basic wallet without additional protection was drained within minutes of the address being published.

The researcher generated a secret phrase on a Coldcard Mk3 device with firmware version 4.1.8 — a model he considers the most vulnerable. Based on this phrase, he created five different wallets, each with the same balance, to test how quickly hackers respond to different levels of protection.

Test Methodology

For the sake of a clean experiment, Cole used a single standard for bc1q addresses, the same key derivation path, and funded each wallet with 10,800 satoshis. All funds were sent in a single transaction. An interesting detail: direct export of public keys to the Sparrow program caused a crash — the device stopped responding to commands, so the researcher had to save CSV files to an SD card.

Five configurations were tested:

  • A standard wallet without a passphrase
  • With a one-word BIP39 passphrase
  • With a two-word BIP39 passphrase
  • With a three-word BIP39 passphrase
  • With a random account number (from 1 to 9999)

The fourth option with three words was replaced by testing a non-zero account number — the researcher wanted to find out whether bots scan non-standard profiles.

Results: The Speed of the Attack Is Stunning

The basic wallet without a passphrase was drained instantly. When Cole opened the mempool explorer, the funds had already been moved to a new unknown address. This means hackers had pre-loaded compromised keys into their automated bots and were waiting for the moment of funding.

The remaining four wallets remained untouched. Even with a one-word passphrase from the standard BIP39 list, attackers could not gain access. The wallet with a non-zero account number also retained its funds. However, the researcher emphasizes: the secret phrase itself is considered fully compromised, and monitoring of address activity continues in real time.

Cole deliberately declined to recover the cryptocurrency via the RBF (Replace-By-Fee) mechanism to preserve the purity of the experiment and avoid distorting data on bot behavior.

My analysis: This experiment is a powerful reminder that a hardware wallet is only part of the protection. If you do not use an additional passphrase (BIP39 passphrase), your funds are at risk, especially when using older firmware. I recommend that all Coldcard Mk3 and older model owners immediately update their firmware and enable passphrase protection. In a world where bots scan the blockchain 24/7, passive security is an illusion.