The issue of hardware wallet security has once again come into the spotlight. My colleague and researcher Cole conducted a bold public experiment aimed at finding out how quickly attackers could drain a wallet created on the basis of the popular Coldcard Mk3 device. The results turned out to be both predictable and alarming.
Methodology: Five Wallets, One Seed Phrase
The researcher generated a secret phrase on the Coldcard Mk3 hardware device with firmware version 4.1.8 — a model he rightly considers one of the most vulnerable. Based on this phrase, five different wallets were created, each with an identical balance of 10,800 satoshis. The differences lay only in the protection scheme:
| No. | Wallet Type | Protection Description |
| 1 | Standard | Without an additional passphrase |
| 2 | With password (1 word) | A word from the standard BIP39 list |
| 3 | With password (2 words) | Two words from the BIP39 list |
| 4 | With password (3 words) | Three words from the BIP39 list |
| 5 | With account number | An arbitrary account number |
For the sake of a clean experiment, all wallets used the same bc1q address standard, a single key derivation path, and sent funds in one transaction. Interestingly, direct export of public keys to the Sparrow program caused a crash — the device simply stopped responding to commands, forcing the researcher to resort to exporting CSV files to an SD card.
Shocking Outcome: Instant Hack
The basic wallet without a password was drained within seconds. As soon as the researcher opened the mempool explorer, the funds had already been transferred to a new unknown address. This is irrefutable proof that hackers had pre-loaded compromised keys into their automated bots, which instantly react to any activity.
The remaining four wallets — with passwords and a non-zero account number — remained untouched. However, the very fact that a secret phrase without additional protection is completely vulnerable is beyond doubt. Monitoring of address activity continues in real time.
My analysis: This experiment is a sobering reminder that even the most reliable hardware wallets are not a panacea. In the era of automated blockchain scanners, leaving a seed phrase without a BIP39 password is like leaving the keys to a safe in plain sight. It is critically important for users to use all available layers of protection, especially if significant amounts are stored on the wallet. Neglecting these measures is a direct path to losing funds.