Tension is mounting behind the scenes in the crypto industry over a new Ethereum improvement proposal — EIP-8363. SharpLink CEO Joseph Shalom has sharply criticized the initiative, arguing that it directly threatens Ethereum's fundamental advantage over bitcoin — the ability to earn income from simply holding assets. The document proposes limiting the share of coins in staking by burning part of validator rewards, which, in the expert's view, could undermine the network's very economic model.
Shalom emphasizes that the yield from locking up funds serves as the base rate for all on-chain markets. This metric is the benchmark for assessing lending rates in protocols, making investment decisions, and calculating the fair value of liquid staking tokens. Reducing rewards will inevitably raise the cost of capital, pushing real yields toward zero. This, in turn, will trigger an exodus of collateral and activity to competing networks, weakening Ethereum's market position.
The SharpLink CEO paid particular attention to the interpretation of issuance as a cost of network security. In his words, this is a fundamentally flawed approach: "Issuance is not a cost Ethereum pays to outsiders. It is a redistribution within the system, from the network to those who protect it and build on it." At the same time, Shalom refrained from criticizing developers, acknowledging their work as diligent.
Mechanics and timeline: what EIP-8363 proposes
The essence of the initiative is the phased burning of validators' consensus rewards. The higher the share of ETH in staking, the larger the deduction. When 60.25 million staked coins are reached (roughly half of the total supply), the reduction rate will hit 100%. The transition period is set at 18 months, which, according to the authors, will avoid a sharp shock to the market.
The draft was published on August 4 — just two days before the deadline for submitting comments on the Hegota update. The tight timeline has already become the main target of criticism from the community. Meanwhile, proposal selection will continue until the end of October, with the update itself not expected before 2027. Currently, about 41.6 million ETH (34% of supply) is staked with an annual yield of 2.65%; nearly 2.5 million ETH is in the queue. The authors calculated that immediate implementation of the mechanism would crash consensus yield from 2.6% to 1.2%, which is why the burning is being introduced gradually.

It is also worth noting that in June, a related initiative called Validator Redirected Revenue appeared on the Ethereum Research forum, proposing a hard fork to allow redirecting up to 10% of staking rewards to fund the ecosystem. This points to a growing trend toward rethinking validator economics.
My analysis: EIP-8363 is a double-edged sword. On one hand, lower inflation could strengthen the "ultrasound money" narrative and attract institutional investors. On the other, a sharp drop in staking yields will undermine the trust of small validators and reduce network decentralization, which in the long run will prove more destructive for Ethereum than current inflation. The market will need time to grasp all the consequences of this initiative, but it is already clear: the debate over the future of staking will become one of the key topics in 2026.