On August 4, 2026, Vladimir Putin signed a law regulating cryptocurrencies in Russia. However, as analysis shows, the mere fact of the document's appearance is only the first step. Serious disputes are flaring up around its key provisions.

I have studied the opinions of leading market participants and highlighted the main pain points of the new legislation. A regulatory framework is undoubtedly necessary, but its design raises questions.

A focus on the banking circuit instead of a project ecosystem

Dmitry Zuev, co-founder and CEO of NGE Farm, notes that the work on the document and its signing are already a big step forward. However, the disputes are not about the fact of regulation itself, but about the chosen model.

"We have bet not on the development of crypto projects, but on integrating exchange into the banking and brokerage sector"

This sector gets the opportunity to create derivatives on crypto assets, such as ETFs, while a rigid custodial centralized circuit is built around decentralized systems. This approach, according to Zuev, is deliberately better than a ban: it opens up a large and varied range of opportunities for the industry. The limitation lies elsewhere — within the country, no environment is emerging in which new crypto projects could be born.

Konstantin Koshelev, a blogger known under the pseudonym "CryptoGrandpa," holds a similar view. He believes the law was adopted solely for the common good. At the same time, the expert speaks of its content with sarcasm:

"At the top, they probably know better not only what cryptocurrency is, but also what it is needed for by the average citizen"

Loans and the liquidity question

Daria Petrukhina, a consultant at IPN Partners, considers the restriction on the circle of persons entitled to provide digital currency under a loan agreement to be the most contentious issue. According to Article 30 of the law, only crypto brokers, trust managers, crypto exchangers, and clearing organizations can act as lenders.

A loan is one of the basic tools for liquidity management, Petrukhina reminds us. Outside the closed list are market participants who hold significant volumes of digital assets but are not VASPs: miners who received currency as a result of their activities, and private investors with large portfolios. In effect, they are deprived of the opportunity to use their owned assets to provide liquidity through the loan mechanism.

There is a certain regulatory logic to the restriction. A digital currency loan agreement could serve as a formal cover for other operations, such as the actual sale of an asset, and control over the execution of such agreements is difficult. The counterargument lies in the law itself: it provides for specialized accounting infrastructure — digital accounts and identifier addresses.

"The movement of a digital asset can potentially be tracked, and the fulfillment of obligations under a loan agreement can be verified"

The issue is especially acute for miners. The law simultaneously blocks their access to loans and establishes criteria under which operations to sell digital currency may require the status of a crypto exchanger. In the Russian regulated circuit, a miner has a limited set of ways to monetize their own liquidity, and one of the few is selling to professional market participants. This gives rise to a separate problem of market pricing: will a miner be able to get a competitive price for their asset, or will they be forced to accept the terms of a limited circle of buyers?

My verdict: the law creates a framework, but leaves key issues of liquidity and competition outside its scope. The market will need time to adapt, and the regulator will need targeted amendments, otherwise we risk getting formal regulation without real industry development.