On August 4, 2026, Vladimir Putin signed a law legalizing the circulation of cryptocurrencies in Russia. However, as my analysis of industry discussions shows, the document turned out to be far from unambiguous. While the very fact of recognizing digital assets is a historic step, a number of key provisions raise serious questions among market participants and lawyers.
Focus on the banking framework instead of an ecosystem of projects
The main conceptual dispute revolves around the architecture of regulation. Instead of forming an open ecosystem for crypto projects, the legislator chose the path of integrating exchange into the traditional banking and brokerage sectors. On the one hand, this opens the door to creating derivatives, including ETFs, and gives the industry far more opportunities than a complete ban. On the other hand, a rigid centralized framework is being built around decentralized systems, which looks like an oxymoron.
Critics rightly note: within the country, an environment for the emergence of new crypto projects will still not appear. The regulatory structure effectively excludes the emergence of decentralized initiatives, leaving only the possibility of their "servicing" through controlled structures. Behind the scenes, this law is called adopted solely "for the common good," yet its content provokes outright sarcasm among experts—it seems that those at the top do not always understand how digital assets should work for the average citizen.
Loans and the liquidity issue: who was left out
The most controversial provision has been the restriction on the circle of persons entitled to provide digital currency under a loan agreement. Article 30 of the law establishes that only crypto brokers, trust managers, crypto exchangers, and clearing organizations can act as lenders.
This decision is a double-edged sword. On the one hand, the logic is clear: a loan agreement could serve as a formal cover for other operations, such as the actual sale of an asset, and control over the fulfillment of obligations in a decentralized environment is extremely difficult. On the other hand, players holding significant volumes of digital assets have been left outside the closed list: miners who receive currency as a result of their activities, and private investors with large portfolios. In effect, they are deprived of the opportunity to use their own assets to manage liquidity through the loan mechanism.
The issue is especially acute for miners. The law simultaneously closes off access to loans for them and establishes criteria under which operations to sell digital currency may require the status of a crypto exchanger. In the regulated framework, a miner has a limited set of ways to realize the extracted liquidity, and one of the few is selling to professional market participants. This gives rise to a separate problem of market pricing: will a miner be able to obtain a competitive price for their asset, or will they be forced to accept the terms of a limited circle of buyers?
The legislator has provided specialized accounting infrastructure—digital accounts and identifier addresses. The movement of a digital asset can potentially be tracked, and the fulfillment of obligations under a loan agreement can be verified. However, this is not enough to compensate for the narrowing of the circle of participants.
My conclusion: the law creates a framework but leaves too many bottlenecks. The main risk is that restricting the circle of lenders and rigidly tying to the banking framework could stifle liquidity and push large holders into the gray zone. The Russian cryptocurrency market has received legal status, but its practical implementation will require significant refinement and, likely, a series of clarifications from the regulator.