The signing of the law on cryptocurrency regulation in Russia is an event that can be called historic for the domestic industry. However, as is often the case, the devil is in the details. I have analyzed the key provisions of the document and highlighted those norms that raise the most questions among the professional community. The controversy is not about the fact of legalization itself, but about the chosen regulatory architecture, which could plant a time bomb under the development of the industry.
Betting on the banking circuit: a step forward or two steps back?
The main conceptual shift is the focus on integrating crypto exchange into the traditional financial system, rather than creating an independent ecosystem of projects. This approach certainly opens up opportunities for the emergence of derivatives, such as ETFs, and that is a plus. But it also implies a rigid centralized circuit around decentralized systems. This creates a paradox: on one hand, we get a variety of instruments; on the other, no environment is formed within the country for the birth of new crypto projects. We risk getting not a market, but an imitation of one, where everything is tied to banks and brokers.
The legislator's motives also raise skepticism. There is a feeling that the law was adopted more for show, for the "common good," rather than for the real development of the industry. This resembles a situation where regulation outpaces understanding of the very essence of the technology.
Loans and liquidity: who is left out?
I consider the most controversial norm to be the restriction on the circle of persons who can issue loans in digital currency. According to Article 30, this right is granted only to crypto brokers, trust managers, crypto exchangers, and clearing organizations. But outside this closed list remain two key categories of players: miners who extract the currency, and private investors with large portfolios. They are effectively deprived of the opportunity to use their assets to manage liquidity through the loan mechanism.
The regulator's logic is clear: a loan agreement could serve as cover for other operations, such as the actual sale of an asset, and control over the fulfillment of such obligations is difficult. However, the law itself offers a solution—digital accounts and address identifiers that allow tracking the movement of the asset and verifying the fulfillment of obligations. In other words, control tools exist, but their use is replaced by a direct ban.
This problem is especially acute for miners. The law simultaneously closes off access to loans for them and introduces criteria under which their sales operations may require crypto exchanger status. As a result, a miner is left with a limited set of ways to realize liquidity, and one of them is selling to professional market participants. This creates a risk of price dictate: will a miner be able to get a competitive price, or will they be forced to accept the terms of a narrow circle of buyers?
My analysis: By creating a rigid structure, the regulator is trying to protect the market from abuse, but risks stifling it in its infancy. Excluding miners and private investors from the loan mechanism is a direct path to reduced liquidity and growth in over-the-counter, uncontrolled transactions. Instead of fighting the shadow, the law creates conditions for its growth. I am confident that in the coming months we will see a wave of discussions and possibly amendments, but for now the market is frozen in anticipation of how the new reality will affect its participants.