A precedent is brewing in U.S. judicial practice that could upend perceptions of the boundaries of commercializing government information. In the Southern District of New York, a lawsuit is being heard that challenges the very possibility of selling priority access to official statements by the sitting president. The plaintiffs insist: the president's posts are government information, and therefore no citizen can have preferential rights to it, even for money.

Business on statements: $100,000 for access to posts

At the center of the dispute is the Truth API service, launched by Trump Media & Technology Group on August 1. The platform provides subscribers with instant distribution of posts from top accounts, and the main "highlight" is the messages of Donald Trump himself. The price tag is impressive: from $60,000 to $100,000 per month. More than ten high-frequency trading companies have already connected to the service, and revenue has exceeded $1 million.

For Trump Media, this is not just money, but a potential lifeline. Against the backdrop of a net loss of $238.1 million with revenue of only $1.7 million in the second quarter, monthly receipts from Truth API could become a key source of survival. Notably, Trump's own wealth, as the largest shareholder, has shrunk during this time from $4 billion to roughly $1 billion.

Constitutional arguments and "pure extortion"

The plaintiffs, supported by the advocacy group Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), appeal to two amendments of the Constitution. The First Amendment guarantees all citizens equal access to official information. Selling priority access creates discriminatory conditions. The Second — the Fifth Amendment — calls into question the very practice of charging "unreasonable sums" for equal access, calling it "pure extortion."

The defendants are not only Trump Media, but also representatives of the White House administration, including presidential aide Natalie Harp and Deputy Chief of Staff Daniel Scavino. Notably, none of them have yet publicly commented on the situation.

Precedents: how regulators have already stopped similar schemes

History knows similar cases. In 2013, Thomson Reuters sold hedge funds access to consumer sentiment data with a two-second head start for $6,025 per month. The New York Attorney General intervened, and the program was shut down within three weeks. Later, under pressure from authorities, Business Wire stopped supplying data directly to high-frequency traders.

The difference is that back then the "commodity" was data from private companies, and now — it is the text of the sitting president, sold by his own company. This time, the issue will likely be decided by a court, not a regulator. And its decision will determine whether a price can be set at all on official statements by the head of state.

My analysis: The situation is extremely ambiguous for the market. If the court sides with the plaintiffs, it will create a dangerous precedent for the entire paid news feed industry, but at the same time it will protect the principle of equal access to information. For crypto investors tracking Trump's posts as a sentiment marker, the court's decision could be an important signal about how legitimate such services will be in the future.