In the U.S. jurisdiction, a precedent-setting case is unfolding that could radically change the rules of interaction between the market and public information. Hearings have begun in the Southern District of New York over a lawsuit challenging President Donald Trump's right to monetize access to his official statements through the Truth API service. The plaintiffs argue that the president's posts are government information, not a private asset, and that selling prioritized access to them violates citizens' constitutional rights.
Business on speed: $100,000 for an advantage
Launched on August 1, the Trump Media & Technology Group service offers clients, primarily high-frequency trading firms, instant delivery of posts from the platform's top accounts, including Trump's own messages. Subscription costs range from $60,000 to $100,000 per month, and more than ten companies have already signed up, generating revenue exceeding $1 million. For Trump Media, which posted a net loss of $238.1 million on revenue of just $1.7 million in the second quarter, this service is a potential growth point that could outpace all other business lines.
The scale of the problem is obvious: Trump's posts have historically moved markets, and access to them with a fraction-of-a-second delay is a liquid advantage. The plaintiffs, backed by the advocacy group Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), insist that such a practice undermines the First Amendment, which guarantees equal access to official information. Selling priority is, in their words, "pure extortion," also violating the Fifth Amendment, since unequal protection of the law undermines the principle of fairness.
Precedents and prospects
History knows similar cases. In 2013, Thomson Reuters sold hedge funds a two-second advantage on consumer sentiment data for $6,025 per month—the program was shut down under pressure from the New York attorney general within three weeks. Business Wire also stopped direct data feeds to traders after regulatory intervention. However, back then the commodity was private company data, whereas now it is the official statements of a sitting president, sold by his own entity.
This is the key difference. A court, not a regulator, must determine whether a price can be set on the public remarks of a head of state. The outcome will set a precedent for the entire market: if monetizing official information is deemed illegal, it will hit not only Trump Media but the entire paid news feed industry.
My analysis: The situation is unprecedented—for the first time, the object of commercialization is not market statistics but political communication. Even if the court rules in Trump's favor, the reputational and legal risks for Truth API are obvious. Investors should closely watch this case: it could become a catalyst for rethinking the entire model of access to sensitive information in the era of digital platforms.