An unprecedented legal case is unfolding in the U.S. jurisdiction: a lawsuit has been filed challenging President Donald Trump's right to sell prioritized access to his official statements through the Truth API service. The plaintiffs insist that the president's public posts are government information and therefore cannot be the subject of a commercial transaction.
The essence of the claims, filed in the federal court for the Southern District of New York, boils down to this: if the president's posts are recognized as government information, then no citizen can gain access to them on more favorable terms than others, even for money. This directly calls into question the business model launched by Trump Media & Technology Group.
Business on speed: $100,000 for an advantage
Launched on August 1, the Truth API service offers subscribers instant distribution of posts from the platform's top accounts, primarily Trump himself. Given that his publications have repeatedly moved markets, demand for such an "informational advantage" has been high. From $60,000 to $100,000 per month—that is the price of access for high-frequency traders. More than ten companies have already connected to the service, with revenue exceeding $1 million.
For Trump Media, which recorded a net loss of $238.1 million on revenue of just $1.7 million in the second quarter, this service is a potential financial lifeline. If monthly revenue stays above $1 million, Truth API could become the company's primary source of income. However, Trump himself, whose stake in the company through a trust was valued at $4 billion and has now fallen to roughly $1 billion, risks losing far more than potential profits.
Constitutional arguments and precedents
The plaintiffs, supported by the advocacy group CREW, appeal to two key amendments. The First Amendment guarantees all citizens and journalists equal access to official information. Selling prioritized access, in their view, violates this right. The second is the Fifth Amendment, which prohibits "unreasonable seizures" and requires equal protection of the law. The lawsuit describes the fee for access as nothing less than "pure extortion."
A historical analogy is also telling. In 2013, Thomson Reuters sold hedge funds a two-second advantage in accessing consumer sentiment data for $6,025 per month. At that time, the New York attorney general intervened, and the program was shut down within three weeks. Later, under pressure from authorities, Business Wire ceased direct data feeds to high-frequency traders. The difference is that back then, the "commodity" was data from a private company, whereas now it is the text of a sitting president, sold by his own firm.
The defendants in the lawsuit include not only Trump Media but also Trump's aide Natalie Harp, Deputy Chief of Staff Daniel Scavino, and the White House administration itself. So far, none of the parties have publicly commented on the situation.
My analysis: This lawsuit is not just a legal conflict but a test of the strength of ethical boundaries between public office and private business. If the court sides with the plaintiffs, it will create a dangerous precedent for all public figures attempting to monetize their information stream. However, even if Truth API is successfully defended, the reputational costs for the president and his company could prove far more significant than $1 million in monthly revenue.