A lawsuit has been filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York that could radically change the rules of how the market interacts with official statements from the nation's top officials. The core of the claims is an attempt by the U.S. president to monetize access to his own posts through the Truth API service, which the plaintiffs argue is a direct violation of constitutional norms.

The lawsuit, filed with the support of the advocacy organization Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), challenges the very possibility of selling priority access to official communications from the head of state. The key argument: presidential posts are government information, and therefore all citizens should have equal access to it, regardless of financial means.

Business on government information: $100,000 for "market movement"

The Truth API service, launched on August 1 by Trump Media & Technology Group, offers clients—primarily high-frequency trading firms—instant delivery of posts from the platform's top accounts, including Trump's own messages. The price tag ranges from $60,000 to $100,000 per month. To date, more than ten companies have signed up, and the service's revenue has exceeded $1 million.

This amount is critical for Trump Media, which posted a net loss of $238.1 million in the second quarter on revenue of just $1.7 million. If the service continues to generate more than $1 million monthly, it could become the company's primary source of income. Meanwhile, Trump's own fortune, as the largest shareholder, has shrunk from $4 billion to roughly $1 billion in recent times.

Constitutional arguments and precedents

The plaintiffs appeal to two amendments. The First Amendment guarantees all citizens equal rights to access official information. Selling priority access, in their view, violates that right. The Fifth Amendment—on equal protection under the law—provides the basis for the argument that charging "unreasonable sums" for equal access is nothing short of "pure extortion."

"Every American has the right to equal access to the president's public statements. Those who pay $100,000 to his personal company do not gain more rights to those statements," is the position of CREW's chief counsel.

History knows similar precedents. In 2013, Thomson Reuters sold hedge funds a two-second head start on consumer sentiment data for $6,025 per month. The program was shut down within three weeks after intervention by the New York attorney general. Later, under pressure from authorities, Business Wire stopped direct data feeds to high-frequency traders. However, back then, the "commodity" was data from private companies, and the price was several times lower. Now, the text of a sitting president is being sold, and it is being sold by his own company.

The defendants in the lawsuit are the White House administration, Trump's aide Natalie Harp, Deputy Chief of Staff Daniel Scavino, and the Executive Office of the President. As of publication, none of the parties had officially commented on the situation.

My analysis: This lawsuit creates a dangerous precedent for the entire industry. If the court rules that selling priority access to statements from top officials is illegal, it will hit not only Trump Media but also any platform attempting to monetize information asymmetry. However, the decision could also be politically motivated, which would only heighten uncertainty for investors in the company's stock.