A fundamentally important legal process is unfolding in the U.S. jurisdiction that could redefine the boundaries between public information and commercial monetization. A lawsuit filed in the Southern District of New York challenges the very legality of the Truth API service launched by Trump Media & Technology Group. The essence of the claims is that presidential posts are government information, not a private asset that can be sold at auction.

$100,000 paywall on presidential posts

Launched on August 1, the Truth API offers clients—primarily high-frequency trading firms—direct and instant access to posts from the platform's top accounts, including Donald Trump himself. The price tag ranges from $60,000 to $100,000 per month. More than ten companies have already connected to the service, with revenue exceeding $1 million. For Trump Media, which posted a net loss of $238.1 million in the second quarter on revenue of just $1.7 million, this service is not merely an experiment but a potential anchor point for the entire business.

Notably, the company's shares, where Trump is the largest shareholder through a trust, have collapsed from $4 billion to roughly $1 billion. Against this backdrop, the Truth API looks like an attempt to find some source of stable revenue.

The essence of the Truth API lawsuit

The plaintiffs, supported by the advocacy group Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), appeal to two constitutional guarantees. First, the First Amendment: journalists and citizens have an equal right to access official information. Selling priority access violates that right. Second, the Fifth Amendment: charging "unreasonable sums" for equal access undermines the principle of equal protection under the law. The complaint directly calls this "pure extortion."

"Every American has the right to equal access to the president's public statements. Those who pay $100,000 to his personal company do not gain more rights to those statements," — this is the position of CREW's chief legal counsel, Nikhel Sus.

The defendants are not only Trump Media but also the White House administration itself, including Trump's aide Natalie Harp and Deputy Chief of Staff Daniel Scavino. Notably, none of them have publicly commented on the situation so far.

Regulators have already banned similar schemes

In Washington, such a development was expected. As early as July 28, Senators Adam Schiff and Elizabeth Warren demanded an SEC investigation, pointing to shares of Citigroup, Palantir, and Coinbase that Trump openly promoted on Truth Social. History knows precedents: in 2013, Thomson Reuters sold hedge funds access to consumer sentiment data with a two-second head start for $6,025 per month. The New York Attorney General objected, and the program shut down within three weeks. Later, Business Wire, under pressure from authorities, ceased direct data feeds to high-frequency traders.

The difference lies in scale and subject: back then, private companies provided the data, and the price was many times lower. Today, the "commodity" is the very text of the sitting president, and his own company is selling it. The decision will likely be made by a court, not a regulator. And it is the court that will determine whether a price can be set on the president's official statements.

My view: This case is a stress test for the entire data monetization industry. If the court rules in favor of the plaintiffs, it will create a dangerous precedent for any platform trying to profit from exclusive access to information that affects markets. But if the Truth API wins, we will see a wave of similar services from all public figures, fundamentally changing the landscape of information transparency.