The New York City Council has initiated an official investigation into the marketing strategies of key prediction market operators. The focus is on Polymarket, Kalshi, as well as Coinbase and Gemini Titan, whose products are closely tied to these platforms. This is the first time municipal authorities have so closely scrutinized promotional practices in this rapidly growing sector.

Lawmakers suspect the platforms of using misleading advertising campaigns, undisclosed payments to influencers, and aggressive targeting of younger audiences, including potentially underage users. Particular attention was drawn to videos showcasing supposedly real profitable trades that turned out to be staged. Cases were also recorded where losing bets were presented as winning ones, which directly encourages gambling behavior.

"Over the past several months, we have studied allegations of predatory marketing practices characteristic of the prediction market industry, which is rapidly developing in New York. Some of these practices raise serious concerns," the council stated.

It is important to emphasize: this investigation does not overlap with a separate lawsuit filed by State Attorney General Letitia James against Kalshi for $36 billion. In that case, the platform is accused of organizing illegal gambling without the appropriate license. Thus, pressure on the industry is coming from two levels simultaneously — municipal and regional.

CFTC tightens requirements for event contract exchanges

In parallel, at the federal level, the CFTC published clarification on the same day for regulated event contract exchanges. The Commission notes a growing flow of applications for incentive programs involving market making, liquidity provision, and product trading, but with serious procedural and substantive shortcomings. The regulator reminds platforms of the need to fully disclose the terms of such offerings and their compliance with the basic principles of licensed exchange operations.

The cumulative effect of these measures impacts the prediction market, estimated at $300 billion. For context: in July, the combined trading volume on Kalshi, Polymarket, and Polymarket US reached a record $50.59 billion. This demonstrates how significant this sector has become and why regulators at all levels are beginning to act in unison.

My expert assessment: The triple pressure — from the city council, the state attorney general, and the CFTC — signals the end of the "gray zone" for prediction markets. If previously platforms could balance between the status of an "information service" and "gambling," now they will either have to radically overhaul their marketing practices or prepare for legal battles. Investors should closely monitor developments: any restriction on advertising activities will directly hit the influx of new users and, consequently, the liquidity of these platforms.