The New York City Council has initiated a large-scale review of the marketing strategies of leading prediction market operators. The focus has been on Polymarket, Kalshi, as well as crypto exchanges Coinbase and Gemini Titan, whose products are closely tied to these platforms.

Lawmakers suspect the companies of using so-called "predatory" promotional methods. This involves misleading advertising, undisclosed payments to influencers, and targeted outreach to young people, including potentially underage users. Particularly concerning are cases where promotional videos showcased supposedly real profitable trades that turned out to be staged. Moreover, losing bets were sometimes presented as winning ones, which, in the council's view, encourages behavior akin to gambling.

"Over the course of several months, we have studied allegations of predatory marketing practices characteristic of the rapidly growing prediction market industry in New York. Some of these practices raise serious concerns for us," the official statement emphasizes.

Notably, this investigation does not directly overlap with New York State Attorney General Letitia James' $36 billion lawsuit against Kalshi. In that case, the platform is accused of organizing illegal gambling without the appropriate license.

CFTC Tightens Requirements for Exchanges

On the same day, at the federal level, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) issued clarification for regulated event contract exchanges. The agency notes a growing flow of applications for incentive programs involving market making and liquidity provision, which have significant procedural and substantive deficiencies.

The regulator reminded platforms of the need to fully disclose the terms of such offerings and ensure their strict compliance with the basic principles of licensed exchange operations. This is a signal that the CFTC intends to more closely monitor how platforms incentivize trading activity.

Both of these measures affect the rapidly growing prediction market segment, which is already valued at $300 billion. For context: in July, the combined trading volume on Kalshi, Polymarket, and Polymarket US reached a record $50.59 billion. Given such impressive growth rates, it is unsurprising that regulators at all levels are beginning to show heightened interest in this sector. The U.S. Congress has already acknowledged the possibility of federal intervention in disputes between the CFTC and state authorities over the regulation of prediction platforms.

My comment: This is just the beginning. Given the scale of the market and its impact on retail investors, we are on the verge of a significant increase in regulatory pressure on the prediction industry. Platforms that rely on aggressive marketing will have to radically rethink their strategies to avoid lawsuits and fines. In the long term, this will clear the market of unscrupulous players, but in the short term, it could lead to user outflows and volatility on these platforms.