The New York City Council has initiated a large-scale review of the marketing strategies of key players in the prediction markets industry. The focus has been on Polymarket, Kalshi, as well as their associated products from Coinbase and Gemini Titan. This is the first time municipal authorities have taken such a systematic approach to analyzing advertising practices in this rapidly growing sector.
The essence of the legislators' claims boils down to suspicions of using misleading advertising, hidden payments to influencers, and aggressive promotion of betting among young people, including potentially underage users. Particular attention was drawn to reports of staged videos that allegedly showed real profitable trades, when in fact they were fabricated. Cases were also recorded where losing positions were presented as winning ones, which directly encourages behavior akin to gambling.
"For several months, we have been studying issues related to allegations of predatory marketing practices characteristic of the prediction market industry, which is rapidly developing in New York. Some of these practices raise serious concerns," the council's official statement reads.
Context: conflict with state authorities
It is important to emphasize that this investigation does not directly overlap with New York State Attorney General Letitia James' $36 billion lawsuit against Kalshi. Regional authorities accuse the platform of organizing illegal gambling without the appropriate license, adding another layer of pressure on operators.
Federal level: CFTC tightens requirements
In parallel with the city's actions, on the same day, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) issued clarification for regulated event contract exchanges. The regulator notes a growing flow of applications for incentive programs involving market making and liquidity provision, but points out their procedural and substantive shortcomings. The CFTC reminds platforms of the need to fully disclose the terms of such offers and strictly comply with the basic principles of licensed exchange operations.
Both measures hit a segment valued at $300 billion. In July alone, the combined trading volume on Kalshi, Polymarket, and Polymarket US reached a record $50.59 billion, underscoring the systemic significance of the issue. The U.S. Congress is already considering the possibility of federal intervention in disputes between the CFTC and states, which could lead to the creation of a unified regulatory standard for the entire industry.
My analysis: This coordinated attack on three levels — municipal, state, and federal — signals the end of the "gray zone" for prediction markets. An industry that grew on aggressive retail user acquisition will now face the need to radically rethink its marketing approaches. In the short term, this could lead to an outflow of liquidity from platforms, but in the long term, it will cleanse the sector of unscrupulous players and strengthen the trust of institutional investors.