The New York City Council has initiated an official investigation into the marketing strategies of the largest prediction market operators. The focus has fallen on Polymarket, Kalshi, as well as related crypto products from Coinbase and Gemini Titan. This is the first time municipal authorities have so substantively examined advertising practices in this rapidly growing sector.
The essence of the legislators' complaints boils down to the platforms' use of misleading advertising, undisclosed payments to influencers, and targeted promotion of betting among young people, including potentially underage users. Particular attention was drawn to videos that showcased supposedly real profitable trades, when in fact they were staged. Cases were also recorded where losing positions were presented as winning ones, which, in essence, encourages behavior akin to gambling.
The council's official statement emphasizes that data on alleged violations was collected over several months. "Some of these practices raise serious concerns," the document notes, indicating the systemic nature of the problem rather than isolated incidents.
It is important to understand that this investigation runs parallel to a larger conflict between New York State authorities and Kalshi. Attorney General Letitia James previously filed a $36 billion lawsuit, accusing the platform of organizing illegal gambling without the appropriate license. Thus, pressure on the sector is being applied from two levels at once — municipal and state.
CFTC tightens oversight of incentive programs
On the same day, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) issued clarification for regulated event contract exchanges. The regulator reported a growing flow of applications for incentive programs, including market making and liquidity provision, which contain serious procedural and substantive deficiencies. The CFTC reminded venues of the strict requirements for disclosing the terms of such offerings and the need for them to comply with the fundamental principles of licensed exchange operations.
Both of these steps target a segment already valued at $300 billion. In July alone, the total trading volume on Kalshi, Polymarket, and Polymarket US reached a record $50.59 billion, demonstrating explosive growth while simultaneously attracting regulators' attention. Given that the U.S. Congress is already discussing the possibility of federal intervention in disputes between the CFTC and states, New York's current actions could become a catalyst for creating a unified, stricter regulatory framework for the entire prediction market.
My view: what is happening is a natural stage in the industry's maturation. Prediction markets have outgrown the status of a niche hobby and now must meet the standards of traditional financial markets. Platforms betting on long-term development should already reconsider their marketing approaches now, otherwise they risk facing not only regulatory fines but also a loss of trust from institutional players, whose arrival is inevitable.