The New York City Council has officially initiated a review of the marketing strategies of key prediction market operators. The focus has fallen on Polymarket, Kalshi, as well as their associated products Coinbase and Gemini Titan. Regulators suspect these platforms of employing misleading advertising campaigns, undisclosed payments to influencers, and aggressive promotion of betting among younger audiences, including potentially underage users.

The basis for the investigation was reports of videos that allegedly showed real profitable trades, when in fact they were staged. Additionally, cases were recorded where losing positions were presented as winning ones, and promotional materials directly encouraged behavior akin to gambling.

"Over the course of several months, we have examined allegations of predatory marketing practices characteristic of the prediction market industry, which is rapidly developing in New York. Some of these practices raise serious concerns," the council's official statement reads.

It is important to emphasize that this investigation does not overlap with a separate conflict between New York State authorities and Kalshi. Recall that the region's Attorney General, Letitia James, has already filed a lawsuit against the platform for $36 billion, accusing it of organizing illegal gambling without the appropriate license.

CFTC intensifies pressure at the federal level

On the same day, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) issued a clarification for regulated event contract exchanges. The regulator notes a growing flow of applications for incentive programs, including market making and liquidity provision, which contain procedural and substantive deficiencies. The CFTC reminds platforms of strict requirements for disclosing the terms of such offers and the need to assess their compliance with the fundamental principles of licensed exchange operations.

Both measures affect a segment estimated at $300 billion. For context: in July, the combined trading volume on Kalshi, Polymarket, and Polymarket US reached a record $50.59 billion. These are colossal figures that explain such close regulatory attention. Earlier, the U.S. Congress already acknowledged the possibility of federal intervention in the dispute between the CFTC and states over the regulation of prediction platforms.

My analysis: This move by New York is not just a targeted review, but a signal of a systemic crisis of trust in prediction markets. If regulators prove facts of manipulative marketing, we could see precedent-setting fines that would force the entire industry to reconsider its advertising strategies. For investors, this means increased legal risks in the short term, but in the long term — a cleansing of the market from dishonest players, which will ultimately strengthen the sector's legitimacy.