While the S&P 500 index was updating historical highs in early August, and gold was confidently storming the level above $4300 per ounce, bitcoin showed striking stagnation, stuck near $64,900. This is almost twice below the October peak. Such dynamics put an end to familiar narratives: a risk asset should have grown along with stocks, and a safe haven should have followed the precious metal. Instead, the first cryptocurrency fell for three consecutive quarters, ignoring both markets.

A dispute without a definition

The decade-long debate about the nature of bitcoin is stalling due to terminological confusion. Back in 2010, researchers Baur and Lucey proposed a clear division: a hedge (weak correlation with the market across the entire history), a diversifier (mitigating fluctuations), and a safe haven (rising on days of crashes). The key problem is that supporters and critics use different samples. If over the long term bitcoin may indeed exhibit diversifier properties, then during periods of extreme stress it consistently falls along with stocks. Both sides are formally right—they are simply talking about different things.

The subject of the dispute has changed three times: from a means of payment to protection against inflation, and then to "digital gold." Each new concept did not have time to accumulate enough data for statistical confirmation before the market refuted it.

Ormuz as a laboratory

The military operation against Iran in late February 2026 became an ideal test. In the first hour, bitcoin dropped by 3.7% to $63,176, triggering $100 million in liquidations. The first test of safe-haven status failed. However, two weeks later the picture changed: bitcoin outperformed both gold and stock indices. BlackRock analysts identified a pattern: in the first ten days of the crisis, the cryptocurrency depreciates, but over a 60-day horizon it shows better returns. This is not protection, but rather a delayed reaction.

Correlation changes sign

2026 brought a surprise: bitcoin's correlation with the S&P 500 reached 0.74 in March, while its correlation with gold went negative (-0.88). The cryptocurrency mirrored the stock market and moved against the metal. But already in the second quarter, the link with stocks broke down to zero. This is not diversification, but chaotic instability. Bitcoin has no intrinsic "anchor" of valuation: stocks are valued through cash flows, bonds through yields, gold through real rates. The cryptocurrency remains without a reference point, making it unpredictable for institutional risk models.

Hopes and reality

The launch of spot ETFs attracted $79.5 billion, and long-term holders control 80% of the supply. However, 2026 became the worst year for bitcoin ETFs: net outflows in June reached $4.51 billion. The Harvard endowment reduced its position in IBIT by 43%, and Jane Street by 71%. "Treasury" companies, including Strategy, are forced to sell coins to make payments on preferred securities. At the same time, CryptoQuant analysts warn: for such companies, the danger is not a crash, but a prolonged sideways trend that undermines investor confidence.

A sign of maturation

Bitcoin's volatility has dropped to 29.2% annually, approaching gold (23%). Fidelity and ARK Invest see this as a sign of maturity. However, the calm may be a harbinger of a powerful move. Comparison with past cycles points to a possible end of the bearish phase by December. The main risk is the overhang of sales from "treasury" companies and miners, 20% of whom operate at a loss with a cost of $78,000.

My conclusion: bitcoin has finally lost its "safe haven" status, but it is also difficult to classify it as a pure risk asset. This is a unique instrument with its own logic, where institutional flows and debt obligations play a greater role than geopolitics. Investors should prepare for high volatility in the coming months, regardless of the market direction.