The failed BIP-110 soft fork was not just a technical mishap, but a clear demonstration that the conditions under which bitcoin was born are irreproducible today. This is the conclusion drawn from an analysis of the events surrounding this proposal, which I conducted together with leading industry participants. The matter concerns an attempt to change consensus rules to combat "junk" transactions — the initiative did not find broad support, and the nodes that switched to the new rules split off into a branch with a negligible share of hashrate.
The key figure in promoting BIP-110 was developer Luke Dash Jr. His strategy for maintaining the viability of the new blockchain included changing the Proof-of-Work algorithm. The very mechanics of this process are telling: the algorithm was to be chosen randomly, based on the hash of a block in Testnet4. However, miners quickly learned to tailor blocks to the desired symbol, which forced the experiment to be abandoned. This, in my view, is a vivid illustration of how centrifugal forces manifest even in "laboratory" network conditions.
The entire coordination of the process was effectively concentrated in one person, who issued instructions via Discord. This is an absolute concentration of centralization, there is nowhere further to go. Such management stands in stark contrast to bitcoin's early years, when the network developed outside the purview of regulators, speculators, and other interested parties. It is precisely this set of circumstances — the "immaculate conception" — that cannot be replicated today, and the failure of BIP-110 only confirms this.
"Moral panic" and a split in the community
I would characterize BIP-110 itself as a complex social phenomenon in which several conflicts were intertwined: disputes over the nature of "spam," questions about Bitcoin Core governance, and the distribution of roles between nodes and miners. Some of the discussions were useful — for example, the very question of the admissibility of arbitrary data in the blockchain is healthy. However, the rhetoric about "illegal content" and "legal risks" created a false sense of emergency, prompting people to act immediately without delving into rational arguments.
Special attention deserves the reaction to Dash Jr.'s removal from the position of BIP editor. This decision looks like an act of retribution rather than a constructive measure. It produces no significant effect, but only fuels the narrative of BIP-110 supporters about the centralization of bitcoin's development process. Earlier, I recall, cypherpunk Adam Back even called this proposal an attack on the reputation of digital gold.
My conclusion: the failure of BIP-110 is not a defeat of a specific idea, but a victory of the network's healthy conservatism. However, the lesson here is deeper: bitcoin has become such a complex socio-economic system that any attempts at "revolutionary" changes from above are doomed. The protocol's true resilience lies in its inability to be captured by any single group of interests, even if that group acts with the best intentions.