The New York City Council has initiated a sweeping review of key players in the prediction market, including Kalshi, Polymarket, as well as crypto exchanges Coinbase and Gemini Titan. This is not merely a formality — regulators intend to thoroughly examine how these platforms promote their contracts on sports events, political outcomes, and even weather phenomena among city residents.

The Core of the Complaints: Marketing Outside the Legal Framework

Council Speaker Julie Menin confirmed that official requests have already been sent to all four companies. They have exactly 14 days to provide comprehensive data: the number of users from New York, a description of advertising methods, the volume of revenue generated from local residents, and other significant information.

The key issue, according to city authorities, is that these platforms effectively fall outside existing regulation. They are not subject to the advertising restrictions and consumer protection measures that are mandatory for casinos and licensed bookmakers in the state. Menin emphasized that the council intends to use all available powers to curb aggressive marketing campaigns that could mislead, especially young people.

"Prediction markets are persistently pushing consumers to bet on sports, politics, culture, weather — practically everything. We will not allow local residents, especially young people, to become victims," Menin stated.

Special attention is being paid to audience acquisition methods. In particular, the council will examine allegations against Polymarket, which, according to available data, used social media influencers to engage young people through "misleading advertising." This refers to videos featuring fake trades on Polymarket copycat sites and staged winning bets that in reality led to losses. Also under suspicion is incitement to trade on insider information.

Federal Context: A Battle of Jurisdictions

This is not the first attack on the prediction industry. Earlier, New York State Attorney General Letitia James filed lawsuits against Kalshi in July and against Coinbase and Gemini in April. The Kentucky Attorney General has also initiated lawsuits against Kalshi and Polymarket, and the Wisconsin Department of Justice has filed claims against a number of platforms, including Robinhood and Crypto.com.

Notably, the federal regulator — the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) — itself sued New York in April, challenging local gambling regulation and insisting on the priority of federal law. At the same time, a federal judge has already stayed the ban on prediction markets in Minnesota, issuing a temporary court order in favor of Kalshi, Polymarket US, and the CFTC.

Responses from the platforms must reach the council within two weeks. The main question remains open: will New York be able to adopt advertising rules that withstand potential federal objections?

My comment: This move by New York is another signal that the "gray areas" in the regulation of prediction markets are rapidly closing. Platforms will either have to adapt to strict transparency requirements or leave the largest jurisdictions. For investors, this means increased regulatory risks in the short term, but in the long term — possible legitimization and institutionalization of the sector. Watch the companies' responses: they will reveal the true scale of their dependence on the New York audience.