The New York City Council has initiated an official investigation into leading prediction market operators, including Kalshi, Polymarket, as well as cryptocurrency platforms Coinbase and Gemini Titan. This is the first time a major metropolis has decided at such a high level to examine the methods used to attract users to trading contracts on the outcome of real-world events.
The essence of the claims and regulator demands
Council Speaker Julie Menin confirmed that official requests have already been sent to all four companies. They have exactly 14 days to provide comprehensive data: the exact number of users from New York, a description of all advertising campaigns, the amount of revenue generated from local residents, and other relevant information.
The key concern of the authorities is aggressive marketing, which they believe may mislead consumers. Particular attention has been drawn to promotional methods targeting young people. Council members emphasize that these platforms effectively fall outside the legal framework, as they are not subject to the strict advertising restrictions and consumer protection measures mandatory for casinos and licensed bookmakers in the state.
"Prediction markets persistently push consumers to bet on sports, politics, culture, weather — practically everything. We will not allow local residents, especially young people, to become victims," Menin stated.
It is separately noted that the investigation will address allegations against Polymarket. This concerns the use of social media influencers to engage young people without the necessary advertising disclosures. Also under review are fake videos with "winnings" on clone sites and staged successful bets that in reality lead to losses. Another point is incitement to insider trading.
Context: federal pressure is mounting
New York is not alone in its efforts to establish order. State Attorney General Letitia James has already filed lawsuits against Kalshi in July, and against Coinbase and Gemini in April. Similar lawsuits have been initiated in Kentucky against Kalshi and Polymarket, while the Wisconsin Department of Justice has filed claims against a range of platforms, including Robinhood and Crypto.com.
Notably, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) itself sued New York in April, challenging local gambling regulations and asserting the primacy of federal law. At the same time, a judge in Minnesota temporarily blocked the ban on prediction markets, siding with Kalshi, Polymarket US, and the CFTC.
Responses from the companies must be submitted to the Council within two weeks. The key question remains open: whether New York can adopt advertising rules that will withstand potential federal objections, or whether this will become another round in a protracted legal battle over the right to regulate this rapidly growing sector.
My take: This investigation is not just a formality, but a signal that the era of the "gray zone" for prediction markets is coming to an end. The estimated $300 billion annual global market is attracting regulator attention, and platforms will either have to adapt to the new rules of the game or face serious restrictions on operations in major jurisdictions. Investors and traders should closely monitor developments: any regulatory tightening could significantly impact the liquidity and accessibility of these instruments.