For the first time in Tether's history, the issuer of the largest stablecoin has undergone a full financial audit. The auditing firm KPMG (USA) issued a "clean" opinion on the 2025 financial statements — the highest rating, indicating the absence of material misstatements and qualifications. However, behind the facade of this historic achievement lies a concerning trend in a key metric.

What exactly KPMG reviewed

The audit covered the activities of Tether International, S.A. de C.V. for the reporting period ending December 31, 2025. This is not the usual "reserve attestation," but a full review of the financial statements: auditors analyzed transactions, ownership documents, asset valuations, internal control systems, and counterparty data. Notably, KPMG specialists personally counted and inspected all the gold bars in the company's accounts, rather than simply relying on custodian reports.

According to the verified data, as of December 31, 2025, Tether's reserves exceeded its liabilities by $6.814 billion. This is the so-called "safety cushion" — a buffer that protects USDT holders from potential losses.

The cushion is deflating: a 40% decline

However, the audit opinion captures the picture at the time of the review. Nearly 20 months have passed since then, and the situation has changed. In the latest quarterly report, prepared by the previous auditor BDO as of June 30, 2026, excess reserves amounted to only $4.11 billion. That is roughly 40% less than the amount confirmed by KPMG.

The halving of the capital buffer in the second quarter looks especially alarming against the backdrop of a recorded net operating profit of about $1.5 billion. Such a discrepancy could indicate either unrealized losses or withdrawals from other reserve segments. The most likely culprit is gold. After the January peak, the spot price of the metal has fallen by more than 20%, and Tether holds a significant portion of its reserves in gold and bitcoin alongside Treasury bills. The company's tokenized gold asset tracks the same metal reserves that KPMG manually counted.

What the "clean" opinion does not cover

Despite the historic nature of the audit, questions remain. The audited legal entity and the group for which the attestation was conducted do not match. Additionally, in its Q4 2025 report, Tether reported a profit of $6.34 billion for the same balance sheet date — roughly $480 million less than in the audited data. The financial statements themselves and the accompanying notes have still not been published, depriving external analysts of the ability to verify the figures and understand the reserve structure.

The audit opinion also does not address the company's ability to conduct redemptions, liquidity under stress conditions, or counterparty risk. These issues become even more relevant as the GENIUS Act rules — the future U.S. regulatory framework for stablecoins — reach the final stretch.

USDT's market capitalization stands at about $183 billion, keeping it in third place among all crypto assets. Tether has met the bar that critics called unattainable. But the real test is the next report and the publication of those very documents signed by KPMG.

My take: Receiving a "clean" opinion from a Big Four auditor is undoubtedly an important milestone for Tether's legitimacy. However, the 40% reduction in the reserve buffer is a signal the market should not ignore. Transparency is not a one-time event but an ongoing process, and investors should closely watch how the company discloses data in the future.