The largest players in the crypto market — Grayscale, Andreessen Horowitz (a16z), and the Crypto Council for Innovation — have sent a collective appeal to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) demanding a review of the approach to regulating new exchange-traded products. The essence of the complaints boils down to the fact that the regulator should not "lump together" all applications for launching ETFs, ignoring fundamental differences in the structure and risk profile of each instrument.
In my analysis, this is a long-overdue signal. The market has moved from the phase of simple spot bitcoin products to complex hybrid structures, including ETFs based on futures, options, and mixed portfolios. Applying outdated norms of the Investment Company Act of 1940 to them means artificially stifling innovation and creating legal uncertainty for issuers.
Key industry demands
The appeal emphasizes the inadmissibility of automatically extending rules designed for traditional funds to products whose underlying assets are not securities. This is especially relevant for ETFs backed by physical assets like gold or commodity futures, where the mechanics of valuation and liquidity differ fundamentally from stocks or bonds.
Among the specific proposals are the introduction of clear and predictable timelines for reviewing applications, as well as the creation of a mechanism for confidential pre-clearance. The latter would allow issuers to receive feedback from the SEC at early stages without publicly disclosing commercially sensitive details, which is currently a significant barrier to market entry.
It is telling that the initiative comes from companies with different business models: an asset manager, a venture fund, and an industry alliance. This indicates a consensus within the industry that the SEC's current regulatory practices do not match the pace of digital asset development. Without a revision of these rules, the U.S. risks ceding leadership in crypto ETFs to more flexible jurisdictions, where regulators have long used the principle of "same action — same risk" rather than a formal approach to classification.
My conclusion: pressure on the SEC will only intensify, especially after recent precedents with the approval of spot bitcoin ETFs. If the regulator does not meet the industry halfway, we may see a wave of lawsuits from issuers who have already gone down this path in the Grayscale v. SEC case and won. The only question is how quickly Washington will realize that adaptive regulation is not a concession but a necessary condition for maintaining the competitiveness of the American financial market.